Multichannel Disc of the Month
“... In sound and performance, perhaps the definitive recording of these magnificent works.” *****
Steven Ritter – AudiophileAudition.com – 21 June 2012
“…orchestra and conductor are utterly convincing in everything in the programme…”
Barry Forshaw – North London News/London 24 – February 2012
Repertoire **** Sound ****
Wie - Fono Forum - October 2011
“…The main attraction of this new release is its clear, colorful SACD sound, showing off the refined playing of this fine orchestra … “
Allen Gimbel – American Record Guide – March/April 2011
“Judging by the number of performances and recordings of Lutoslawski’s music since his death, his reputation remains deservedly high; this outstanding Chandos disc comes as the first of a new series of his orchestral works. It is most welcome, for Gardner has the measure of these outwardly similar but essentially different scores… Three important works in Lutoslawski’s output, therefore, launch this series; if the succeeding issues are as good as this in terms of interpretative and recording qualities, it should be an unbeatable set.”
Robert Matthew-Walker – Classical Recordings Quarterly – Winter 2010
“The BBC Symphony brings its richness and majesty to Lutoslawski’s colourful, clever and compelling music. …In particular conductor Edward Gardner emphasizes Lutoslawski’s gifts for counterpoint and contrast; ever layer is clearly audible, each musical voice brilliantly defined.”
Julian Day – limelightmagazine.com.au – 5 April 2011
“…With detailed but immediate SACD sound …, the disc can be warmly recommended …”
Richard Whitehouse - International Record Review - December 2010
“…this album offers Chandos’ luxuriant SACD sound, and Edward Gardner and the BBCSO’s familiarity with the considerable technical demands of these works.” ****
Phillip Sommerich - Classical Music Magazine - November 2010
"Editor’s Choice”
“Making a case for Lutoslawski in advance of his centenary…This performance sets the seal on a disc that leaves one eager for its successors.”
Arnold Whittall - Gramophone magazine- December 2010
Performance **** Recording *****
Martin Cotton - BBC Music Magazine - December 2010
****
Andrew Clark - Financial Times - 16 October 2010
“Exciting performances of exciting music.” ****
Paul Driver - The Sunday Times - 24 October 2010
“…Gardner’s performance is impressive – vivid, incisive and well controlled…” ****
Andrew Clements - The Guardian - 15 October 2010